HCI Q2 Deep Dive: Technology and Underwriting Discipline Drive Profitable Growth, Exzeo IPO in Focus

Insurance and technology company HCI Group (NYSE:HCI) reported Q2 CY2025 results exceeding the market’s revenue expectations , with sales up 7.6% year on year to $221.9 million. Its non-GAAP profit of $5.18 per share was 15% above analysts’ consensus estimates.

Is now the time to buy HCI? Find out in our full research report (it’s free).

• Revenue: $221.9 million vs analyst estimates of $219.4 million (7.6% year-on-year growth, 1.1% beat)

• Adjusted EPS: $5.18 vs analyst estimates of $4.50 (15% beat)

• Operating Margin: 42.5%, up from 36.9% in the same quarter last year

• Market Capitalization: $1.82 billion

HCI Group’s second quarter results were well received by the market, reflecting robust execution in both its insurance and technology businesses. Management credited the quarter’s performance to disciplined underwriting, operational leverage, and technology-driven risk selection, particularly in the Florida homeowners market. Chief Operating Officer Karin Coleman highlighted that Exzeo’s proprietary technology allowed HCI to identify improvements in Florida’s underwriting environment ahead of competitors, enabling rapid and profitable scaling. CEO Paresh Patel noted that HCI’s ability to select and retain the right customers has supported a retention ratio of approximately 90%, while gross loss ratios continued to improve, demonstrating the effectiveness of the company’s technology and strategy.

Looking forward, HCI Group’s guidance is centered on leveraging its technology platform and maintaining underwriting discipline as competition intensifies, especially in Florida. Management emphasized that the recently launched reinsurance program and the planned Exzeo initial public offering (IPO) are expected to be pivotal for future growth. President of Exzeo Kevin Mitchell stated, “We believe the best path is to pursue an initial public offering of Exzeo shares,” underscoring the company’s commitment to unlocking value. The company remains cautious about market volatility outside Florida but expressed confidence in its ability to identify new opportunities using data-driven approaches.

Management attributed the quarter’s success to lower loss ratios, expanding operational leverage, and the strategic use of proprietary technology, while also emphasizing progress toward spinning off Exzeo as a separate entity.

• Technology as a differentiator: Proprietary software developed at Exzeo enabled HCI to detect and capitalize on favorable shifts in Florida’s underwriting environment ahead of peers, supporting rapid premium growth without sacrificing risk standards.

• Underwriting discipline and retention: Management credited strong underwriting standards and focused risk selection for a roughly 90% customer retention rate and a reduction in gross loss ratio to below 25%, even as policy counts increased.

• Operational leverage improvement: The company reported ongoing declines in operating expenses as a percentage of revenue, resulting in a combined ratio below 62% for the quarter—a measure of overall insurance profitability excluding investment income.

• Reinsurance strategy executed: HCI completed its reinsurance program for the upcoming treaty year, with management noting that a conservative approach ensures protection against catastrophic events. The full impact of the new program will be reflected in the next quarter’s results.

• Progress on Exzeo IPO: The company confidentially submitted a registration statement for an Exzeo IPO, viewing the separation as a means to unlock value for both the core insurance business and the technology arm. Management did not provide specifics but indicated that Exzeo’s independence will allow greater focus and growth for each segment.